I have a 2005 z71 crew cab with a procomp 8in suspension lift kit running 35in tires with the stock 3.73.gears. I am wanting to regear the axles but am unsure what ratio to go with. I am torn between 4.10 and 4.56s. Anyone with first hand experience or just any help would be nice.
2005 Chevy Silverado 1500 Z71 Crew Cab
8in ProComp Suspension Lift, 4in Shackle Flip Kit, 3in Performance Products Body Lift, 17x9 Moto Metal wheels, 35x12.50x17 ProComp Xterrains, K&N cold air intake kit, Custom 3in exhaust, GoRhrino Black spring loaded steps, Truxedo Bed Cover, "SS" style Instrument Cluster with blue pointers and Trans Temp Gauge, JVC indash touchscreen DVD player, 2 MTX 10in subwoofers, Sony Xplode 1000watt amp, Radio Shack CB with dual black whips, Optima yellow top battery




Welcome to the site! We have had this discussion before and the verdict was the 4.56's would be your best bet as the 4.10's would only be a slight difference from your stock 3.73's so if you are going to spend the money to re-gear, go with the 4.56's.
Darcy
Washington State
2006 Silverado 2500HD LT3 4X4 CC SB Duramax LBZ
Tuff Country 6" lift, 35" Toyo M/T's on 20" Ultra Peacemaker wheels, Quadzilla Stealth2 programmer, Diamond Eye 5" cat-back exhaust, factory Special order color Yellow.

I have some experiences
What do you plan on doing with the truck? Is it a DD or are you going to actually use instead of it being a parking lot queen?
If you are going to be using it as a DD, then I'd suggest 4.56s. 4.56s will regain the lost torque and low end power caused by lifting the vehicle and adding the larger tires but it will keep you on the fuel efficient side.
4.88s would be an excellent choice for you if you plan on going to larger tires, such as 37s, or if you are going to be using this thing off road.
In my opinion, 4.10 isn't even an option here. If you are going to spend the money to have the vehicle regeared, then go with 4.56s or 4.88s. You will be very happy that you did. Once I got my truck regeared, it was like night and day. Now, I can bark tires driving down the road and spin the crap out of them from a stop.
Regear, your tranny will thank you in the long run!
2005 Chevy Silverado Z71 in Black
6" BDS Suspension Lift | 3" BDS Body Lift |17" Rock Crawler Stellies | 35" Cooper STTs | 4.56 Yukon Gears | AirAid CAI and TBS | Flowmaster 40s | HyperPAC Programmer
2001 TJ Sahara in Sienna
3.5" RE Suspension Lift | 33x12.50 Baja MTZs | D30/44 | ROKMEN Merc Front Bumper | Warn Rockcrawler Rear w/ Carrier | Warn M8000 Winch
Yes it is a daily driver but I only put maybe 10-15 miles on it per day at the most. I do take it out every now and then probably would go out more often if it was regeared. I have thought about going to 37s in the future but I dont feel the 10bolt axle will be strong enough. With your truck are you happy with the 4.56s or would you rather go with the 4.88s? Thanks for the help.
2005 Chevy Silverado 1500 Z71 Crew Cab
8in ProComp Suspension Lift, 4in Shackle Flip Kit, 3in Performance Products Body Lift, 17x9 Moto Metal wheels, 35x12.50x17 ProComp Xterrains, K&N cold air intake kit, Custom 3in exhaust, GoRhrino Black spring loaded steps, Truxedo Bed Cover, "SS" style Instrument Cluster with blue pointers and Trans Temp Gauge, JVC indash touchscreen DVD player, 2 MTX 10in subwoofers, Sony Xplode 1000watt amp, Radio Shack CB with dual black whips, Optima yellow top battery

I'm very happy with it. The original plan was to go with 4.88s, but they couldnt get them in, in time. If you wanna take it off road, and are only going 10 miles to work, then I'd go with the 4.88s. Especially, if you are toying with 37s.
From what I've read and what I've asked on these and other boards, there are a couple of people that are running 37s on the 1/2 ton axles with no probs. Everyone has told me to do it, just not to stomp on the gas running down the highway and not to take it off road and beat the hell out of it.
I think I'm gonna do it.
2005 Chevy Silverado Z71 in Black
6" BDS Suspension Lift | 3" BDS Body Lift |17" Rock Crawler Stellies | 35" Cooper STTs | 4.56 Yukon Gears | AirAid CAI and TBS | Flowmaster 40s | HyperPAC Programmer
2001 TJ Sahara in Sienna
3.5" RE Suspension Lift | 33x12.50 Baja MTZs | D30/44 | ROKMEN Merc Front Bumper | Warn Rockcrawler Rear w/ Carrier | Warn M8000 Winch
4.88 gears would be nice either way , im running 4.56 with 35s and im happy with them. As far as 37s go i dont know if i would be willing to try after a buddy of mine burnt up his 10 bolt rear running 37s ,but 2 things that may have contributed is the tires were 37 x 15, and it was a suburban so it was pushing a little more weight. True , it may be fine if you dont punch the gas hard, but how can you resist at times lol. Not to mention if your towing anything your chances are greater for damaging your axle.
Life's short... Drive hard!
1990 GMC Suburban 4x4 w/ jasper 355
6" Skyjacker suspension lift w/ Interco Trxus sts 36 14.5s
on Mickey Thompson classic rims, Edelbrock
intake, K&N 14 x 4 filter, JBA shortys
Magnaflow exhaust, Pioneer system with
Dual 12 inch subs... The list goes on!
4:56 gears work the best for 35's
I just installed 4.56's in my 97 chevy with 35's and I turn 1900 RPMs at 60 MPH. I love the ratio for driving back a forth to work. ( 26 miles one way) I highly recommend the 4.56's, you wouldn't even notice the difference between 3.73 and 4.10

2005 Chevy Silverado Z71 in Black
6" BDS Suspension Lift | 3" BDS Body Lift |17" Rock Crawler Stellies | 35" Cooper STTs | 4.56 Yukon Gears | AirAid CAI and TBS | Flowmaster 40s | HyperPAC Programmer
2001 TJ Sahara in Sienna
3.5" RE Suspension Lift | 33x12.50 Baja MTZs | D30/44 | ROKMEN Merc Front Bumper | Warn Rockcrawler Rear w/ Carrier | Warn M8000 Winch
Bookmarks