Decided to bite the bullet and bought myself a new set of wheels. I ended up buying the XD series black "Hoss" wheel in a 20x9 size. The original plan was to use the stock LS-2 tires until the tread wore out but they are even worse when on a wider wheel so I bought nitto terra grapplers a week after. Below are some before and after pics for your viewing pleasure. Before: After: Close-up of wheel and Nitto Terra Grappler tire: Let me know what you all think!