Synthetic or regular motor oil

Discussion in 'Chevy Suburban Forum (GMC Yukon XL)' started by spyder, Jan 18, 2009.

  1. spyder

    spyder New Member

    I have a 2001 suburban 2wd 1500 with 217k miles on it. Should I start using the synthetic oil to help with it's performance or stay with regular?
  2. retired

    retired Rockstar 100 Posts

    With that kind of mileage stay with regular oil.
  3. jchambers849

    jchambers849 Member

    If it's always had regular, stick with it. Synthetic has been known to leak if used on older motors that have never seen it before... I know. I had a perfect T100 with 170k on it on regular oil... changed to synthetic for the mileage benefits and to get it to last even longer, and ended up with a puddle on the driveway... leaks didn't stop even after I changed back to regular. Rebuild wasn't too far after.
  4. jn1965

    jn1965 Member

    I would do the switch to Mobil 1. BUT, and it is a big BUT, it will clean all the gunk from inside the engine. I just switched to M1 in the Mercedes with almost 300,000 miles on it. What you should do is change the oil and filter at 3000 miles and then change it again at 3000 miles. After that you can extend the interval. You can also have the oil analyzed at Blackstone labs to see how much life is left in it.

    If you get any leaks, don't worry about them. The leaks are caused by the gunk being cleaned away from the gaskets. The gaskets will swell with synthetic stopping the leak after a while.

    Didn't the 2001 come with M1 from the factory? My 1999 did. It says fill only with Mobil 1 on the oil filler just like my '96 Impala SS had.
  5. jchambers849

    jchambers849 Member

    I agree that Synthetic will basically "flush" the engine. That can sometimes be bad as well... loosening up gunk. I've read that when changing to synthetic, its not a bad idea to do another change only 1000 miles after.

    I disagree with the leaks stopping... mine only got worse. I changed at 1k miles, then every 3k, adding quart after quart of synthetic due to the new leaks that appeared, until I finally tore her down 15k after switching to Mobil 1 syn... wouldn't have had to if I had stayed with dino oil, i'm sure of it.

    I'm a TRUE believer on synthetic from day one or switching on lower mileage vehicles, however. I had an explorer that had synthetic amsoil in every possible place from day one... I sold it with over 300k with the original motor, trans, transfer case, front and rear ends... and that vehicle was worked hard.
    Last edited: Jan 18, 2009
  6. Allmostsmart

    Allmostsmart Rockstar

    I agree that it might cause a leak, but if you want to extend the life of your motor I would switch to synthetic. you might have to replace your valve cover gaskets and oil pan gaskets and maybe the rear main seal, but in the end it would be worth it. Your rings and bearings will reap the benefit.
  7. vncj96

    vncj96 Epic Member 5+ Years 1000 Posts

    I woudlnt do it with that high of mileage, but if you do your first run on the synthetic should NOT be more then 1000 miles, the synthetic will break down all the gunk and it needs to get out of there quickly. This is the way the dealerships do it as well, very low miles on the first run of synthetic
  8. venom909

    venom909 New Member

    What is considered “High Mileage”? Is it too late to make the change on my 2001 w/ 90K?
  9. phoebeisis

    phoebeisis Epic Member 5+ Years 1000 Posts

    I bought my 1998 2wd about 20 months ago with 195,000 miles on it.I use Mobil 1 5w30 in both vehicles- no problems-at 208,000 miles now..

    The "leaks from switching to synthetic" might be a holdover from the early synthetics.One early synthetic-it was called something or other Graphite?? Graftex?? I really can't remember the exact name, but it was soooo thin that it leaked from every seal.Even worse it had graphite suspended in it, so the leaky oil was this jet black stuff-really a nasty mess.

    I haven't had any leak problems, but I do use one quart per 3000 miles. This seems about right for a 208,000 miles motor,so I don't worry about it.

    In truth it probably won't matter one way or the other since most of its life has been on standard oil.Regular oil is pretty good now.If it was 100,000 or less I would switch for sure.

  10. spyder

    spyder New Member

    Thanks everyone for the feed back

Share This Page

Newest Gallery Photos