The Dreaded P0420 code ...

Discussion in 'General Chevy & GM Tech Questions' started by ajwade, Jan 27, 2011.

  1. ajwade

    ajwade New Member

    Hey y'all. I stumbled upon this site and I have to say, great job. I'm pretty excited to be able to bounce around ideas in here!

    Now... I drive a 2000 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 with a 5.3. I'm at 160,000 miles and the truck is running like a champ, gas mileage is great (or as great as it ever was) and I really can't complain. About few months ago I was driving from NC to GA and the SES light came on. I stopped by the closest Autozone to make sure it was ok to keep driving and got the P0420 code... The truck was running fine, so I continued to GA, took it to a local shop and had them put it on their computer. It was showing that it was lean on banks 1 and 2. Long story short, we changed the fuel filter, reset the code, and voila... No more P0420... Until about 1,000 miles later. This time it only showed being lean on bank 1. I changed my gas cap, reset it, and about 300 miles later it came back on... So...

    I realize I tried some pretty inexpensive band aids for what is likely a larger problem (like the cats...) but I thought I'd run it by some of y'all and see what you think. It just seemed unlikely that both banks would show lean simultaneously, then not trip the code for so long??

    Any ideas would be much appreciated. I just can't drop $1500 bucks or so into a truck with 160,000 miles right now... That being said, I love my truck!!

    Too bad I'm in NC and not GA... Dadgum inspection... :grrrrrr: I figure it's a Silverado, not a Prius... I'm leaving a nice carbon footprint cats or no cats! :glasses:
  2. 99'HEARTBEAT

    99'HEARTBEAT Moderator


    Trouble Code P0420 may mean that one or more of the following has happened:

    • Leaded fuel was used where unleaded was called for
    • An oxygen sensor is not reading (functioning) properly
    • The engine coolant temperature sensor is not working properly
    • Damaged or leaking exhaust manifold / catalytic converter / exhaust pipe
    • Retarded spark timing
    • The oxygen sensors in front and behind the converter are reporting too similar of readings
    Possible Solutions

    Some suggested steps for Troubleshooting a P0420 error code include:

    • Check for exhaust leaks at the manifold, pipes, catalytic converter. Repair as required.
    • Use a scope to diagnose the oxygen sensor operation (Tip: The oxygen sensor in front of the catalytic converter normally has a fluctuating waveform. The waveform of the sensor behind the converter should be more steady).
    • Inspect the downstream heated oxygen sensor (HO2), replace if necessary
    • Replace the catalytic converter
  3. mad1500hd

    mad1500hd New Member

    X2 what 99'Heartbeat said...but FWIW, i did all that too, and still had to replace the CATs...i'm in california, so i think my cats may be more expensive than every where else (damn cali emissions)...but very good troubleshooting technique...

    good luck!
  4. ntbush83

    ntbush83 New Member

    Hey instead of losing money just cut the cats out and sell them! :) Do they really inspect for cats in NC??
  5. Welcome to the club.
  6. ajwade

    ajwade New Member

    Thanks boys... Unfortunately, they certainly do inspect cats in NC... Dadgum police state...

    The thing that is throwing me is how I had no code, then a code for both cats, changed a fuel filter, and no code... Seems odd that both cats would go out simultaneously. Kind of like both your headlights going out at the same time... It ain't the bulb.

    I do have the infamous "cold tick" as well that is attributed to carbon build up... Think there could be a correlation?

    Or you think I'm just not dealing with the reality that Ole White Lightnin' is getting old? ;-)
  7. stephan

    stephan New Member

    I think orriginally when you had "lean on both banks 1 & 2" it was just a plugged fuel filter rather than 2 bad cats, since replacing the F F fixed it for 1,000 miles before it threw any more codes. For your current prob I would follow Heartbeats & Cadis diag. & swap the sensors. If the prob follows the sensor then the sensor is bad. If the problem stays put after the swap then it would indicate 1 bad cat on that side, but you could still have the exhaust leak so you should check for that first before spending money for the cat.

    If you do have to replace the cat, don't let the shop keep the old one. Like Nutbush says those things are worth money & you can sell it to a scrapper. They buy them for the platinum.
  8. ajwade

    ajwade New Member

    I appreciate all the help fellas... I'm going to do some "experimenting" this weekend. I'll definitely keep y'all posted. In the event that I do need cats, Caddiac, you have a link to where you purchased yours?
  9. ajwade

    ajwade New Member

    Alright boys... I need some help understanding some numbers. I could "Google around", but I figure you boys are a trustworthy crew.

    I hooked up to an OBDII scan reader today and got this freeze frame data:

    P0420 (lean bank 1)
    STFT B1(%) 3.93
    LTFT B1(%) 21.88
    STFT B2(%) 2.34
    LTFT B2(%) 21.88
    MAP(kPa) 39.00
    Engine RPM 526
    Veh Speed 0
    MAF(g/s) 4.55
    TPS(%) 0.00

    I have a general understanding of some of that data. I do know that STFT bascially means the short term adjustments and LTFT is long term... Clearly my discrepancy is between STFT on bank 1 and STFT on bank 2... I was under the assumption that you were shooting for plus or minus 25 for a combined STFT and LTFT with a normally functioning cat. So my bank 1 combo would be 25.81 and my bank 2 would be 24.22... Seems like a ball park to me????

    Don't you miss the good ole days when we just climbed into the engine compartment of our trucks with a cold beer, a ratchet ,and a grin????

    I appreciate all y'all's help.
  10. ajwade

    ajwade New Member

    Just as an update... After clearing the code, running a tank of 93 octane, and driving 100 miles, the SES light came back on as expected. This time, all the numbers were the same, except the STFT on bank 1... It was 0.00% and STFT on bank 2 which was -1.56.

    Any insight? I'm going to switch the back 02 sensors tomorrow and see what happens.

    As an interesting note though... I've noticed that the SES light only triggers when I'm stopped, maybe even when I have the wheel slightly turned. (It tripped today when I was pulling in my driveway to get the mail...) Could a loose vacuum hose on the power steering pump be possible?
    Last edited: Jan 30, 2011
  11. phoebeisis

    phoebeisis New Member

    Big aside-
    Some low life-MF-"MIGHTY FRIENDLY" advertise on Craigs List-that they buy CatCons.
    Ok I understand you want to get the word out, but scrappers get every catcon anyway-from the muffler guys.
    Yeah, you want to make sure you get them, but
    They-the MFs- are encouraging ripping off catcons.
    With a cordless angle grinder it is pretty easy to crawl under a truck and cut them off.
    My Suburban isn't insured for theft-so catcons hacked off off would be a big expense-not like they try to avoid other lines when they are stealing them.
    Don't know why this particularly pisses me off this am.NOLA has HUGE PROBLEMS with copper and aluminum thefts-strip houses, destroy outside AC units, stealing aluminum guardrails.
    Charlie
  12. ajwade

    ajwade New Member

    Update!!

    Alright guys... Got an update and a follow up question.

    So I checked my PCV valve and it was in rough shape. Changed it and the "knocking" noise I had disappeared. I cleared my check engine light and I've driven about 500 miles and it hasn't came back on... hmmmm...

    All would seem well (at least for the time being) but my emissions status is still showing up as "not ready". All the tests have ran (including the catalytic converters and o2 sensors) except the EVAP monitoring system...

    How long should it take for this system to complete its cycle?? Is this indicative of something else or do I need to just quit being obsessive compulsive and drive for a while?

    I appreciate it!

Share This Page